Since 2018, I’ve been adapting a 3-paragraph writing assignment that I stole from John Roberts at Florida State University. In this post, I’ll explain the assignment, its requirements, my advice to students, and what I like about this assignment. You’re welcome to adapt this assignment for your own purposes, of course.
Continue reading A 3-Paragraph Writing AssignmentCategory: Academia
Upon Reflection, Ep. 13: Reflection-Philosophy Order Effects and Correlations Across Samples
Suppose you glance at a clock that, unbeknownst to you, is broken, showing the same time all day. Nonetheless, you happened to look at the clock precisely when it showed the correct time. So your belief about the time is correct. My question is this: did you know what time it is?
Perhaps you think that you did. After all, you formed a belief on the basis of a device that most people trust and the belief was true! What else would it mean to know something? Well, in academic philosophy, the orthodox answer to this kind of thought experiment is “no”.
People who perform better on tests of reflective thinking tend to report philosophers’ orthodox answer to this kind of thought experiment. And, if you’ve been following my research, you know that philosophers are particularly reflective thinkers. These correlations may make you wonder about causation. Does thinking reflectively cause people to accept philosophers’ orthodoxy? Or is it the other way around: does studying thought experiments like the broken clock case somehow result in people performing better on reflection tests?
In this episode, I’ll tell you about the experiment I ran to find out. The paper is titled “Reflection-Philosophy Order Effects and Correlations Across Samples” and has been accepted for publication in Analysis. The paper will also mention a bunch of other thought experiments, tests of reflective thinking, and measures of research participants’ data quality.
Continue reading Upon Reflection, Ep. 13: Reflection-Philosophy Order Effects and Correlations Across SamplesPodcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 30:51 — 42.4MB)
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | TuneIn | RSS | More
Oppenheimer: âPhilosopher-Scientist-Statesmanâ
J. Robert Oppenheimer âwas widely known not just for his scientific success but for his remarkably wide-ranging knowledge of the humanities [,âŚ] an extraordinary combinationâŚâ, says Ashutosh Jogalekar in his 8th and final post about Oppie over at 3 Quarks Daily (2023). Why do I start with this quote? I think it alludes to an important lesson for our time. I explain in less than 700 words below.
Continue reading Oppenheimer: âPhilosopher-Scientist-StatesmanâHereâs to the Philosopher-Scientists!
Sometimes philosophers complain that scientists do philosophy badly and that philosophers may thereby be underrated. The idea is that people could have better philosophy if they just turned to academic philosophers rather than the popular scientists that have done philosophy badly. (Perhaps analogous complaints about philosophers circulate among scientists). In this post, I want to turn our attention to scientists that do philosophy well and philosophers that do science well.
Continue reading Hereâs to the Philosopher-Scientists!Non-Western Philosophy of Mind
I have been considering changes to my Philosophy of Mind syllabus. One kind of change would be to include non-Western philosophies and philosophers. So I did what every scholar of our era does when it’s time to venture in to new territory: I asked #PhilosophyTwitter. In this post, I’ll share the results.
Continue reading Non-Western Philosophy of MindHow To Prepare For A Thesis Defense
I defended my doctoral dissertation in 2020âyes, remotely. I also defended a master’s thesis a few years earlier. I learned a few things and sought plenty of advice between these two defenses. In this post I will share the checklist that I used to prepare for the dissertation defense.
Continue reading How To Prepare For A Thesis Defense6 Tips For Academic Presentations
Like many academics, I’ve given dozens of academic presentations and dozens more audio and video interviews in the past few years. After a series of subpar presentations, plenty of feedback, and lots of practice, I now get remarkably positive feedback on these presentations. For example, some professors have advised their graduate students to model their job talks after some of the talks that I have given about reasoning, morality, and religion. In this post, I’ll share the best advice for academic presentations that I have received so far, focusing only on what I have found to be most helpful.
Continue reading 6 Tips For Academic Presentations10 Steps For Organizing A Conference or Workshop
Organizing a conference or workshop is time-consuming yet important work. I have organized a handful or international conferences, in-person and online. In this post, I distill my conference organizing experience into a list of 10 steps to make your conference or workshop a success. To find out more about organizing conferences/workshopsâespecially onlineâsee Online Conferences: Some history, methods & data
Continue reading 10 Steps For Organizing A Conference or WorkshopA Year On The Job Market With A Ph.D. â Some Data
I was on the job market in the Fall of 2019 and the Spring of 2020. I submitted over 280 job applications to universities, governments, companies, think tanks, and grant agencies. After some interviews, job talks, and a few offers, I thought that I would share my experience here (and in this video conversation). If at any point you have questions, then feel free to contact me on your platform of choice; I’ll see if I can answer your question in a future post. Today’s post visualizes data about the job market process from application submission to job offer.
Continue reading A Year On The Job Market With A Ph.D. â Some DataUpon Reflection, Ep. 5: Reflective Reasoning For Real People (Dissertation Overview)
Welcome to Upon Reflection. In this episode, I review the major take-aways and findings from my dissertation titled, “Reflective Reasoning For Real People”. I explain what cognitive scientists mean by terms like “reflective reasoning”, how reflection is measured empirically, how reflection can either help or hinder our reasoning, how more reflective philosophers tend toward certain philosophical beliefs, and how reflection may help us retrain our implicit biases.
Continue reading Upon Reflection, Ep. 5: Reflective Reasoning For Real People (Dissertation Overview)Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 15:53 — 29.1MB)
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | Amazon Music | TuneIn | RSS | More